Scientists Cooked Thanksgiving Dinner in June. It Made the Worst Air in the House.

A month of sensors in a Texas test home points to three free kitchen habits. None of them needs a filter or a new stove.

You open a window when you burn the toast. For most people, that's the only time the air in the kitchen crosses their mind.

But you cook in that room every day. Eggs in the morning, a pan of something at night. And if you're past 50, there's a good chance your kitchen is where the whole family ends up when they visit.

Here's what few people are told. The smoke you can't see may be the part that counts. And the fix costs nothing. It comes down to the burner you pick, how you cook your vegetables, and a fan you already own...

In June 2018, two scientists borrowed a house in Texas to find out what an ordinary home does to its own air. Marina Vance, an engineer at the University of Colorado Boulder, and Delphine Farmer, a chemist at Colorado State University, led the project. The house sat on a research campus run by the University of Texas at Austin. It was a plain, 1,200-square-foot home, packed with sensors.

For a month, the team did what people do at home. They cooked. Then they cleaned, and opened windows, and shut them again.

One test was a little strange. The team cooked a full Thanksgiving dinner in the middle of a Texas summer. Turkey, stuffing, Brussels sprouts, sweet potatoes and cranberry sauce all went on the menu. Vance later joked that it's "surprisingly difficult to find a whole raw turkey in June."

Four volunteers did the cooking. Twelve guests came to eat. And the windows and doors stayed shut, the way they would on a cold November day...

This Is How Your Drinking Water Speeds Up Memory Loss By 50%

Scientists at the University of New Mexico just made a shocking discovery:

Inside the water you drink every single day, there are invisible toxic shards silently building up inside your brain…

Strangling your brain cells like a snake…

Crushing the connections that keep your memory sharp…

And speeding up memory loss by 50% every 8 years.

If you want to see what's erasing your memory daily — and stop it before it's too late — you need to check this out now:

The Worst Air Of The Whole Month

That meal made the dirtiest air the team saw in the entire study. Vance said so herself.

Take a look at the numbers. Fine particles in that kitchen climbed past 250 micrograms in each cubic meter of air. For scale, the U.S. limit for outdoor air, averaged over a whole day, is 35. A spike is not a full day, of course. But it's a big spike.

Even plain toast pushed the count higher than the team expected.

So the team ran the math on what a person would breathe in and keep after 12 hours in that kitchen. On a quiet day with no cooking, it came to about 7 micrograms. Their Thanksgiving day hit 149. That's roughly 20 times more.

Then came the part that caught my eye. After some meals, a person in the room would have taken in more of the smoke after the cooking stopped than during the cooking itself. The burners were off, yet the haze was still hanging in the room...

Why A Speck You Can't See Matters

Let me explain what "fine particles" are. They're bits of soot, smoke and oil so small that about 30 of them could sit side by side across one hair.

Big dust gets caught in your nose. These tiny bits slip past and settle deep in the lungs, and some of the smallest may reach the blood.

So what do they do over years? The best answer we have comes from outdoor air.

Brigham Young University: Arden Pope's team used American Cancer Society records on about 500,000 U.S. adults, followed from 1982 to 1998. People who lived in cities with more fine particles had a higher risk of dying from heart and lung disease, about 6% higher for each step of 10 micrograms per cubic meter.

That was outdoor air, breathed for years. It's not one skillet on a Tuesday night. Pope himself said the risk was far smaller than the risk from smoking. Still, it tells you these specks are worth taking seriously.

The Pan Decides More Than You'd Think

Where does kitchen smoke come from? Mostly from the food and the oil, not just the flame. A gas burner adds gases of its own. Yet on any stove, hot oil makes smoke.

A team at the National University of Singapore tested five ways to cook the same food: steaming, boiling, stir-frying, pan-frying and deep-frying. Deep-frying raised the number of particles in the air about 24-fold. Steaming barely moved it, and boiling stayed low too.

Labs in Europe have found the same pattern since. Hotter pans make more smoke. Grilling and searing sit at the top, while cooking in water sits at the bottom.

That's good news for your plate. Think steamed broccoli, simmered green beans, or a pot of beans on low. Those are the very foods you want more of anyway.

Here's the thing. The gentlest way to cook a vegetable is also the cleanest way for your air.

The Fan Over Your Stove Has A Sweet Spot

But you won't steam everything. You'll still sear a fish or brown an onion. That's where the hood comes in.

Engineers at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory in California tested 15 kitchen fans as they were installed in real homes. Some pulled out nearly all the fumes. Others caught under 5%.

And one choice mattered over and over: which burner the pan sat on. Back burners did far better in almost every case. Front burners let more of the fumes slip into the room. The flat-bottomed fans built into microwaves were among the weakest.

You see, most hoods don't reach out over the front of the stove. Put your pan on the back, and the fumes rise straight into the fan.

The Part I Can't Promise You

I'll be plain about the limits. I couldn't find a long study that followed back-burner cooks to see who stayed healthier. The Texas house was one house, for one month. And the big death numbers come from outdoor air, not from kitchens.

So treat this as a free habit with good reasons behind it. It isn't a cure for anything. Fresh air isn't only something you go outside to find. Sometimes you have to make room for it at home...

Three Things Worth Knowing At The Stove

01

Back burner, fan on first

Put the hot pan on a back burner. Turn the fan on before the oil heats, not after you smell smoke. A higher setting pulls more, so use it for searing and frying.

02

Let the fan run after you eat

In the Texas house, some of the worst exposure came after the cooking ended. Leave the fan on for 10 to 15 minutes once the stove is off. No hood? Crack the window nearest the stove while the pan is hot.

03

If the oil smokes, it's too hot

That wisp off the pan is the very thing you're trying to keep out of the room. Turn the heat down a notch. Or add a splash of water and a lid, since water keeps the pan from getting hot enough to smoke.

HERE'S WHAT I'D DO THIS WEEK

  • Cook two vegetable dishes in water. Broccoli in a steamer basket, green beans simmered under a lid, or a pot of beans on low.

  • Move every hot pan to the back. All week, every meal, with the fan on before the burner.

  • Give the fan ten more minutes. When the plates hit the table, leave it running.

  • Keep your doctor in the loop. If you have asthma or a heart or lung condition, ask about kitchen air at your next visit, and keep taking what you've been prescribed.

The Texas team cooked Thanksgiving in June to see what a normal home does to its own air. Even they were surprised by what they found. A busy kitchen can make the worst air in the house.

But you have more say over this air than any air outdoors. Nobody can move a highway. You can move a pan.

So this week, cook your vegetables in water, not in smoke. Use the back burner and let the fan run. Then notice how the kitchen smells by Friday.

Stay well,
Whole Food Medicine

Subscribe